Skip to content

1 Comment

  1. Elisa C.
    August 17, 2024 @ 00:43

    There’s something about Chicago 16 that brings the best in nearly everything about Chicago to me. All the songs are solid. Cetera and Champlin are amazing vocally, apart and together. The finest session players were called to fill the gaps, but resulted in some hard feelings. Foster always has the reputation for perfection. Bringing in studio guys got the record done faster, and gave extra time for the band members to learn the techniques and new skills (brush up on other instruments, synths, drum machine, find a permanent guitar player, etc)

    Apparently, Jimmy Pankow did a favor for Toto at the time: He plays Trombone on “Rosanna” on Toto IV. After all the session work the Toto guys did for Foster, I suppose that was the least he could offer. I’ve heard rumors of other small contributions, but they aren’t verified. But, “What You’re Missing” was written by Jay Gruska and Joseph Williams, soon to be in Toto.

    The band was NOT over Terry Kath, and never healed from the trauma. Instead, the remaining members were hard on anyone new. Bill Champlin said he never felt accepted by the band, and despite singing several hits, he was treated like a sideman. Jason Scheff, who replaced Cetera, was treated a little better, but subtly the band was NOT 100% with him – they brought in guitarist/singer, Keith Howling to supplement the higher background vocals, until he left for a long while while he recovered from an arm injury. He came back about 7 years later (not quite sure of the date exactly). Scheff remained on vocals and bass until he left the band in 2016 due to family issues.

    As a result of lingering anger and sadness over Kath’s death, nobody could fulfill his role without some backlash. Champlin said directly, that while he is the same vocal range as Kath was, he couldn’t imitate him perfectly!
    He took the worst of the anger. Yet Champlin was up front about playing a good rhythm guitar but was no Kath. Champlin did have one talent that caused some jealousy – he is a fine Hammond B3 player and pianist, and had picked up some technique from David Foster. Champlin has an amazing voice, good songwriting skills, and apparently Kath was a fan of the band Sons of Champlin.

    When Foster came in, he did a great job producing the hits, helping write songs, and arranging the symphonic addictions to the music and bringing a 1980’s flash to the band. The horn section felt discarded at times, but out of the three albums he produced, Chicago 16 used quite a bit of brass – 17 had little, and 18 was in the middle, horn-wise. I just wish Foster had engaged the band in more songwriting on Chicago 17 and 18, especially since 16 was strong song-wise.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.